Vanish vs Incogni: Why 2,300+ Brokers Beats 180
Bottom Line
Incogni covers roughly 180 data brokers and charges $11.99/month (or $5.99/month on an annual plan). Vanish covers 2,300+ brokers across 17 categories for $4.99/month — that's 12× the coverage for less money. Vanish also includes a free scan, dark web monitoring, manual removal guides, and user-submitted broker reports. If you're comparing Incogni alternatives, Vanish wins on every metric.
Quick Comparison: Vanish vs Incogni
| Feature | Vanish Best Value | Incogni |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $4.99/mo | $11.99/mo |
| Annual price | $59.88/yr | $77.88/yr ($5.99/mo billed yearly) |
| Free scan | ✓ Yes — see results before paying | ✗ No — subscribe first |
| Data brokers covered | 2,300+ brokers | ~180 brokers |
| Coverage categories | 17 categories | ~10 categories |
| Auto-removal requests | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Dark web monitoring | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| IoT / Smart device data | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Manual removal guides | ✓ Yes — for stubborn brokers | ✗ No |
| User-submitted broker reports | ✓ Yes — community-powered | ✗ No |
| Ongoing monitoring | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Annual savings vs Incogni | $18–$84 saved/year | — |
Prices verified as of April 2026. Incogni bills $11.99/month or $77.88/year ($5.99/month). Vanish bills $4.99/month with no annual lock-in. Broker counts sourced from each service's public documentation.
Price: Vanish saves you up to $84/year
Incogni's monthly plan costs $11.99/month — that's $143.88/year. Their annual plan drops to $5.99/month ($77.88/year), but you're locked in for 12 months upfront.
Vanish costs $4.99/month with no annual commitment. That's $59.88/year — saving you $84 versus Incogni's monthly plan, or $18 versus the annual plan. Either way, you pay less for 12× the coverage.
The real kicker: Incogni doesn't let you see results before paying. With Vanish, you run a free scan first — see exactly which 2,300+ brokers have your data — then decide if $4.99/month is worth it. Zero risk.
Broker Coverage: Vanish covers 12× more sites
Incogni covers approximately 180 data brokers, concentrated on US and Canadian people-search and data aggregation sites. It handles the basics — Spokeo, BeenVerified, Whitepages — but stops there.
Vanish monitors 2,300+ data broker sites across 17 distinct categories:
- ✓ People Search & Background Checks
- ✓ Marketing & Ad-Tech databases
- ✓ Financial (Credit Bureaus, BNPL, Specialty)
- ✓ Public Records aggregators
- ✓ Health & Insurance data brokers
- ✓ Dating Sites
- ✓ Genealogy & DNA databases
- ✓ Employment & HR databases
- ✓ Phone / Spam Databases
- ✓ Retail & Loyalty programs
- ✓ Travel & Transportation
- ✓ Education data
- ✓ Dark Web Monitoring
- ✓ IoT & Smart Device databases
- ✓ Telecom & ISP data
- ✓ Social Media aggregators
Incogni misses dark web monitoring, IoT/smart device data, financial specialty databases, and several other categories entirely. These aren't niche concerns — dark web brokers trade email credentials and SSNs on underground marketplaces, and IoT brokers collect behavioral data from connected home devices. If your data is in those places, Incogni won't find it.
What Incogni Does Well
Fair comparisons build trust. Here's where Incogni has genuine strengths:
- ♦ Backed by Surfshark. Incogni is developed by Surfshark, a well-known VPN provider. If you already use Surfshark, bundled pricing can make Incogni affordable as an add-on.
- ♦ Clean, simple dashboard. Incogni's interface is straightforward and well-designed. You see removal requests, their statuses, and estimated completion times in a clear layout.
- ♦ GDPR/CCPA-focused approach. Incogni leans on privacy regulations to compel brokers to comply with removal requests. This works well for the brokers they cover, particularly in jurisdictions with strong privacy laws.
These are real advantages. But for most people searching for an Incogni alternative — particularly those who want broader coverage — the gap between 180 brokers and 2,300+ is too large to ignore.
Why Switch from Incogni to Vanish
If you're already using Incogni, here are the concrete reasons to make the switch:
12× more broker coverage
Incogni covers ~180 brokers. Vanish covers 2,300+. That's not a rounding error — it's an order of magnitude. Every broker Incogni misses is a place your data still lives.
Lower price, no lock-in
Vanish is $4.99/month with no annual commitment. Incogni's best price ($5.99/month) requires you to prepay for a full year. On monthly billing, it's $11.99 — more than double Vanish.
Dark web monitoring included
Vanish monitors underground marketplaces where stolen personal data is bought and sold. Incogni only covers surface-web data brokers and has zero dark web visibility.
Manual removal guides for stubborn sites
Some brokers don't respond to automated removal requests. Vanish provides step-by-step manual removal guides for these sites. Incogni leaves you with no fallback — if their automated request fails, you're stuck.
Community-driven broker reports
Vanish users can submit new data brokers they discover, growing the coverage database faster. Incogni's broker list is maintained internally with no community input.
Where Vanish Wins
Price
- ✓ $4.99/mo — no annual commitment
- ✓ 58% cheaper than Incogni monthly
- ✓ Up to $84 saved every year
Free Scan First
- ✓ See your exposure before paying
- ✓ 2,300+ brokers scanned instantly
- ✓ No credit card for the scan
12× Broader Coverage
- ✓ 2,300+ brokers vs ~180
- ✓ 17 categories vs ~10
- ✓ Dark web + IoT coverage included
Beyond Automation
- ✓ Manual removal guides included
- ✓ User-submitted broker reports
- ✓ Coverage grows with the community
The free scan alone changes the equation. Incogni asks you to subscribe before seeing any results. With Vanish, you scan 2,300+ brokers for free, see exactly where your data lives, and then decide if $4.99/month is worth it.
Who Should Choose Which
Both services automate data removal requests. Here's an honest breakdown of who each fits best:
✓ Choose Vanish if…
- ✓ You want to see results before committing money
- ✓ Budget matters — $4.99 vs $11.99 monthly
- ✓ You want the broadest coverage (2,300+ brokers)
- ✓ You need dark web or IoT data monitoring
- ✓ You want manual guides for stubborn brokers
- ✓ You want no annual lock-in to get started
— Consider Incogni if…
- → You already use Surfshark VPN and want a bundle
- → You only need coverage for ~180 major brokers
- → You prefer a VPN company's privacy ecosystem
- → Price is not a deciding factor
For the majority of people landing on this page — people actively evaluating Incogni alternatives — Vanish is the better choice. More brokers, lower price, free scan, dark web monitoring, and manual removal guides. The coverage gap (2,300+ vs ~180) alone makes the decision straightforward.
Try Vanish free — scan 2,300+ brokers in 30 seconds
See exactly which data broker sites have your personal information, before you pay anything. No credit card required for the scan.
Start Free Scan →Free scan · No credit card needed · Results in 30 seconds
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from people comparing Vanish and Incogni: